Copyright and IPStandards

Software as a service: LEO Lane and contractual regulation of 3D designs

Stay up to date with everything that is happening in the wonderful world of AM via our LinkedIn community.

LEO Lane, an Israeli firm that offers intellectual property protection to the additive manufacturing industry, uses algorithms to regulate the use of clients’ designs. The company responds to a growing concern about safeguarding intellectual property across the AM sector, which is defined by its decentralization and the consequent transmission of electronic data. Electronic data is inherently difficult to regulate: it does not recognize borders. Enforcing copyright, trademark or patent infringement involves costly legal proceedings; LEO Lane designs its service to prevent litigation.

LEO Lane’s service

The service prevents litigation by controlling an intellectual property holder’s design through LEO’s terms of use. Companies and individuals who wish to have their designs remotely printed or licensed to a foreign printer sign up for LEO’s web service. LEO’s software safeguards the client’s intellectual property by acting as a gatekeeper.

LEO protects its clients’ privacy and rights by only requiring a critical piece of a design, which is removed from the encoded limited edition object (hence the term ‘LEO’). The client retains the full LEO file, while LEO Lane’s cloud retains the comparatively small missing piece. The client’s product requires that piece to function correctly. LEO communicates the missing design element from its cloud service to a local printer, which completes the design, thus authorizing replication. The client can then count the number of times that a product is printed and bill the printer accordingly.

Printers, moreover, can easily use LEO Lane’s software on most available print systems. LEOs are relatively large files that can be read in various printer formats. They are loaded to the printer under the client’s control; LEO Lane supplies the small missing piece from its cloud. LEO Lane’s software is compatible with partner systems from Materialise, SAP, Accenture, Shapeways, GE and Autonomous Manufacturing.

LEO’s software also secures product design against human error. The LEO encodes design specifications. These details are immutable on the printer-side: the designer can, for example, specify permissible material types, compatible AM technology, permitted scaling and the number of items printed in a run from a single LEO file. These restrictions give designers control over all aspects of production. Designers can monetize their intellectual property with ease.

LEOLane's privacy protection process and related features
LEOLane’s privacy protection process and related features

A wider look at industrial regulation

The effect of LEO’s cloud service is to use international software-as-service-agreements as a form of regulation. This approach is endemic in the media industry, and SaaS contracts have grown in lockstep with the industry. The public cloud services market has grown more than four-fold since 2009. It is expected to grow by another third between now and 2022. The AM sector, however, has not yet taken SaaS up to facilitate knowledge transfer.

SaaS has the potential to regulate large swaths of an industry because terms of service are contracts that bind users to companies’ conditions. These conditions become the heart of regulation, while companies become gatekeepers that adjudicate compliance and disputes. Facebook and Twitter are examples of large companies able to regulate large user bases; LEO’s approach is more personable, but the concept at work is similar. The contract that opens users to use LEO’s software for knowledge transfer requires users to submit to LEO’s rules.

This kind of requirement is, to be sure, reasonable in a commercial exchange. Taking a broader view of the requirement’s effect on an industry suggests a push-and-pull between SaaS providers and clients. Providers channel legal and moral rules into the industry, which ensures a measure of fair play. Clients governed by these schemes may demand, much like citizens of a republic, different rules to suit an industry or segment. Providers with a sufficiently large client base go a step further to define their industries’ knowledge sharing through their rules.

The difficulty, if one must be pointed out, in SaaS regulation is that legal agreements are only vehicles for regulation. The software implements companies’ rules, which means that companies must be particularly attuned to clients’ concerns.

Indeed, the key to knowledge transfer is trust between each player in the transfer chain. LEO builds trust by ensuring that its service is secure, and its customers feel secure. The company offers to sign non-disclosure agreements with corporate clients after preliminary discussions about service options. These two-way contracts exist apart from LEO’s terms of use. They protect LEO’s proprietary algorithm and clients’ designs and trade secrets.

Takeaways

Contracts, especially international contracts, move business forward. When enough contracts are administered by a single company, the company becomes a focal point for business interests. These points frequently arise in the provision of software or computing platforms. They are, to boot, an indispensable part of the AM ecosystem. Decentralized knowledge transfer needs flexible gatekeepers to guarantee property rights and quality.

LEO Lane is an example of a flexible gatekeeper. Its cloud service builds privacy, discretion and control into intellectual property distribution. In so doing, it curries favor with industry partners like its printing partner systems. As the industry grows, LEO and other service providers will begin to serve as points of reference for industry protection standards. Clients may notice this movement; governments and international organizations like the World Intellectual Property Organization may also at some point take heed to craft more formal standards.

 

This article is part of a series on law and additive manufacturing. If you or your company has experience with this or other legal issues, please tell us about your experience by emailing adam@3dpbm.com.

*October 28, 2020 — This article has been modified from its original version to amend some technical inaccuracies.*

Research 2021
Ceramic AM Market Opportunities and Trends

This market study from 3dpbm Research provides an in-depth analysis and forecast of the ceramic additive ma...

Adam Strömbergsson

Adam is a legal researcher and writer with a background in law and literature. Born in Montreal, Canada, he has spent the last decade in Ottawa, Canada, where he has worked in legislative affairs, law, and academia. Adam specializes in his pursuits, most recently in additive manufacturing. He is particularly interested in the coming international and national regulation of additive manufacturing. His past projects include a history of his alma mater, the University of Ottawa. He has also specialized in equity law and its relationship to judicial review. Adam’s current interest in additive manufacturing pairs with his knowledge of historical developments in higher education, copyright and intellectual property protections.

Related Articles

Back to top button

We use cookies to give you the best online experience. By agreeing you accept the use of cookies in accordance with our cookie policy.

Privacy Settings saved!
Privacy Settings

When you visit any web site, it may store or retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the form of cookies. Control your personal Cookie Services here.

These cookies are necessary for the website to function and cannot be switched off in our systems.

In order to use this website we use the following technically required cookies
  • PHPSESSID
  • wordpress_test_cookie
  • wordpress_logged_in_
  • wordpress_sec

Decline all Services
Accept all Services

STAY AHEAD

OF THE CURVE

Join industry leaders and receive the latest insights on what really matters in AM!

This information will never be shared with 3rd parties

I’ve read and accept the privacy policy.*

WELCOME ON BOARD!